Tent Series Evaluation - Preface Read the full article >>

prologue

There is nothing more important than a tent in the wild life. A well-functioning tent will allow you to take a full rest after a long day outdoors. No matter what the outside environment is, you can stay in a tent leisurely. Enjoy a cup of hot tea. It can be said that it is our other home. Moreover, in some emergent and harsh environments, a strong tent can provide you with adequate security protection.

In this evaluation activity, we got altogether 7 tents; we first measured the detailed parameters of the tent and made a table, and then made some necessary analysis of the structure of the tent, windproof, compressive, and waterproof. Test and summarize the unity of opinions within the group. Two of them, HOLIDAY and black-yak, are Korean brands, and they are positioned in the mid-to-low-altitude three seasons and half months, and all of the performances are relatively perfect. Therefore, we evaluate the other tents in terms of their quality and comprehensive performance. As a reference standard.

The other five tents are snow wolf-Snow Wolf; SCALER-Skeller; MOBI GARDEN-Grappets; ACME-Accam; TOUREAD- Pathfinder. These are domestic products, of which MOBI GARDEN - Mobicoma is a brand that has just entered the market, many consumers do not understand this brand, TOUREAD - Pathfinder is the country's first outdoor brand, but consumers have been We are not very satisfied with the quality of the brand's products, so we conducted special tests on the tents of these two brands, which tested the ultimate bearing capacity of tent poles.

The functional positioning of these five tents is basically a low-altitude hiking and camping tent. The overall structure is basically the same and the details are different. So we pay more attention to the differences in the details and focus on different places. Their differences are mainly focused on the connection between the post pole and the inner bill. There are two types of aluminum rods, which are divided into full metal parts, which are inserted into the post design, and metal loops where the post of the semi-metal part is inserted into the nylon strip; The design of the account connection bar foot and the design of the inner account door are also very different.

In the evaluation tent structure, we focused on the design of the tent's internal account, the external account, the external gate, and the vents and the joints.

In the wind and pressure test of the tent, we simulated the pressure of wind and snow and tested the direction of the tent. Among them, there are cases where nails and wind ropes are used well and nails and wind ropes are not hit. By comparing different situations, we can clearly see the impact of the striking nails and wind ropes on windproof and compressive performance of tents.

In the evaluation of the waterproof performance of the tent, we took a splash of water and a static water pressure test. The splashing of water was pouring a certain amount of water on the flattened external account to see if the water could flow quickly and not stay on the account area. The account is drenched. Static water pressure test is to let the tent's external account and account bottom respectively receive a certain depth of stagnant water, the depth of water to control the size of the water pressure, the speed of the water seepage phenomenon began to evaluate the strength of the tent waterproof capacity.
HOLIDAY (Great Adventure) tent evaluation Black yak (NEW CABANE DOME 2P) tent evaluation ACME (ACME-004) tent evaluation MAGODI (catching wind 2) tent evaluation pathfinder (Wrangler ET0113-3) tent test Skelele tent Evaluation of snow wolf tent evaluation

Review

After two weeks of evaluation, we have an overall understanding of these seven tents. In addition to HOLIDAY and BLACK YAK, these tents are all domestic brands. The positioning of domestic brands is low-altitude three quarters. Among these five domestic brands, the differences in the work and design of the tents are still quite significant.

HOLIDAY and BLACK YAK are three-quarter and half-half tents of mid-to-low altitude. Their workmanship and design are relatively mature, and HOLIDAY has the best overall performance. It is also the heaviest of the evaluation tents at the same time. BLACK YAK has the disadvantage of being short on the narrow side of the account. In addition, the price of BLACK YAK is very high and it is not worth buying. So if you choose a tent that needs to be used in a harsh environment and it is urgent to use it, HOLIDAY is the choice for such consumers.

The prices of the remaining five domestic tents are relatively close to each other, roughly between 300 and 400, and they are positioned at low-altitude three quarters; however, some of these outstanding brands can be used in the winter environment when the environment is not very harsh. The brand of these five tents is: ACME-Accam; MOBI GARDEN-Mugaidi; TOREAD- Pathfinder; SCALER-Skeller; SNOW WOLF-Snow Wolf.

Looking at the tents of the five brands in China in general, their fabrics are not very different. There is almost no difference in the fabric between ACME-Accam, MOBI GARDEN-Mugaidi and TOREAD- Pathfinder. The difference in workmanship is not very obvious. The most important difference is reflected in the design of the tent. The difference in design determines the overall performance of the tent.

After conducting a series of tests on the five tents, the team unanimously agreed that ACME and ACCEM's ACME-004 are the best performers. At the same time, it is also relatively affordable, it is worth buying; of course, the evaluation team recommended consumers to buy Accam ACME-006 models, that is, a two-door design, many members of the group have used ACME-006, Very much trust in its quality. ACME-004/006 is suitable for long-distance walking: moderate weight, large internal space, solid design and excellent materials make the hiker feel comfortable and safe at home.

Although MOBI GARDEN-Mugaidi's Breeze 2 is quite excellent in terms of various indicators, the water-repellent nature of this book is not high; and the height of the wind collecting at 2.18 m makes it less unstable than ACME. -004/006 is a lot less impressive. It eventually did not stick to our destructive tests and the poles were bent (of course, the possibility of such a strong pressure under real conditions is relatively small). Therefore, Mulgudi's Breeze 2 is suitable for use in leisure activities. If consumers want to enjoy the fun of leisure activities, the height of Breeze 2 can make people sit upright and half inside, and the spacious bottom area can also maximize people's relaxation. This type of consumer can choose to pick wind 2; the wind has a height of one meter three, and 3 can accommodate 3 people to choose from. The team did not evaluate the first two series of MOBI GARDEN-Mugigadi: SUMMIT, Summit series, TREKKING, and Trekking series. We have great hope and interest in these two series of products as long as no water is deposited on the bottom of the book. The problem of low sexuality, these two series of products is still quite looking forward to.

The TOREAD- Pathfinder tent performance was not particularly satisfactory. The internal height of 99 cm was the shortest among the seven tents tested, which seriously affected the activities of the personnel in the account. There was dew or frost within the account. The activities of the people in the account are even more likely to have very bad consequences.

The combined performance of SCALER-Skeller and SNOW WOLF-Snow Wolf was ranked behind us by three tents. Although there are bright spots in some areas, these two tents are still not competitive at the same price.

These are the horizontal conclusions we have made after evaluating these seven tents. The above conclusions represent the common point of view within the assessment team, but due to the limited number of products in contact, our opinions may be biased, and there may be better products that are not mentioned by us. We will refer to them in subsequent tests. .

The shortcomings of various tents are summarized

HOLIDAY

No special feedback

BLACK YAK

The length of the narrow side of the tent outside the account is not enough, and there is no fixed nail design in the middle of the narrow side. It is easy to cause the situation in which the foreign account and the internal account are affixed together.

ACME-Akkam

The olive buckle tether is not long enough, and it takes a lot of effort and time to fasten the inner bill with olives. The fabric of the outer tent seems to be thinner than the old ACME.

MOBI GARDEN-Mugadi

1. The water resistance of the bottom of the book is not satisfactory. Water seepage begins within five minutes. It is estimated that the quality of the PU coating does not pass, and it is definitely not up to the target of the PU3000. 2. The material of the internal account is not very detailed, but it is not as good as that of Arkham.

TOREAD - Pathfinder

1. There is no reinforced connection between the outside account and the inside account. The tent is too low in height and there are no vents. 2. The two awnings in the outer tent were too spacious, resulting in a large area at the bottom of the tent. The four wind ropes were not sufficient to effectively maintain the stability of the tent. 3. The internal account double-entry screens have the gauze design on the inside and it is very inconvenient to adjust the size of the vent at night. And the double-layered interior door is a separate design. It is necessary to pull two zips to open the inner door. The design is not scientific. 4. The external accounts are connected with the plastic fasteners at the bottom corner of the account, giving people a feeling of unsafe and not strong.

SCALER-Skale

Fabrics and various details of the work is not ideal, loose accounts loose, can not be tight within the account.

SNOW WOLF - Snow Wolf

The design of the snow skirt is more than necessary, and the foreign account is loose. It cannot be tight on the inside of the account. The fabric of the inside account is not as good as that of Arkham.

Eye Shadow

Eye Shadow,Eyeshadow Palette,Cosmetic Eyeshadow,Colorful Eyeshadow Palette

Guangzhou Yafei Makeup Toiletry Co.,Ltd , https://www.yfmakeupbrush.com

Posted on